The projects will be judged on the following criteria:
TOPIC
- Has the student clearly identified the
soil science issue they have investigated?
- Has the student demonstrated a
comprehensive understanding of the soil science issue they have investigated?
SCIENTIFIC PROCESS
Evidence of ownership
- Has the student shown evidence from the report and journal that
they have completed the investigation and acknowledged assistance given?
Aim & Hypothesis
- Has the student clearly stated a valid
researchable question based on the student's own research?
- Has the student proposed and justified a
reasonable hypothesis?
Logical Scientific Procedure
- Has the student designed, assessed and
modified (if necessary) and carried out their own experimental design with
attention to accuracy and precision?
- Has the student followed a logical and
appropriate process, used valid scientific controls with replication where
appropriate?
- Has the student demonstrated
thoroughness and persistence in their approach to their project?
Data
- Has the student determined the type of
data to be collected and identified procedures for validating the
authenticity and reliability of the data?
- Has the student used valid data
collection methods and effectively employed appropriate technologies?
Results
- Has the student shown that the results
were gathered accurately and comprehensively?
- Has the student presented the
information using formats that demonstrate results, relationships and
sources clearly, accurately and succinctly?
Interpretation
of Results
- Has the student interpreted the results
in a valid and logical way?
- Has the student assessed the accuracy
and relevance of any measurements and calculations and identified trends
and anomalies (secondary only)?
Conclusion
- Is there adequate data to support the
conclusion?
- Is the conclusion consistent with the
aim of the investigation?
SKILL
Appropriate
Use of Materials
- Has the student demonstrated safe and
effective use of materials and equipment?
COMMUNICATION
Visual Presentation
- Is the project visually appealing,
creative and easy to follow?
Readability
- Is the text well written and easily
understood?
Appropriate
Use of Illustrations
- Have illustrations/diagrams/maps, etc.
been used to convey information in a clear and interesting way?
